It’s Valentine’s Day – so in the spirit of love and charity, here’s some free advice. Consider it my contribution to consumer protection.

There are a lot of PR professionals out there who have a pony with but one trick in this new medium. They have one answer to every question. They’ve got a hammer, and all they see are nails…etc, etc, blah, blah.

Prospective clients have read the articles in Business Week, they’ve heard the chattering classes wax poetic about the Power of A Fully Operational Blogosphere. They ask their agency of record, “what can you do for me in this blog-thingy?” If it’s an agency of clout or influence, they might have a designated blogger meandering about – or they go out and find a specialty firm: Blogs R Us.

In the end, the answer is always the same: with zombie like repitition, they deliver the goods, “You must have a blog. It’s the only way to engage in real conversation. You’ll never be taken seriously if you don’t have this bright shiny object that I can sell you for just this small five-figure retainer.”

Ah, so many words come to mind. Not many of them printable on a family blog. So let’s settle for two: hogwash and chutzpah.

Repeat after me: you don’t need a blog. Or more precisely, you might need a blog – but your interest in the medium alone is hardly dispositive. Actual participation as a blogger is a big step that demands serious committment. It can certainly bear fruit – in the right circumstance.

But it. Is Not. For Everyone.

Far, far, far more important – is a plan that includes strategy and tactics to ENGAGE the blogs that are already there. If you don’t have that in place – I don’t care how many trackbacks you send or timestamps you fudge – you’ve been sold a bill of goods.

So, friends – here’s your handy reference chart: if the first thing your consultant recommends is starting a blog – run away. Don’t look back, don’t pass GO.

You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

3 comments so far

  1. Robert J. Ricci

    February 15th, 2006 at 10:39 am

    Couldn’t agree more. Did you happen to see the series of blog-related articles in latest issue of New York magazine (http://nymag.com/news/media/15967/)? Oof!

  2. Chuck Tanowitz

    February 16th, 2006 at 9:14 am

    It’s funny, when I suggested that the term “blogger relations” is just too limiting for what’s to come, I got slammed for it. But it’s part of the same discussion. No, blogging is not for everyone. We should be encouraging our clients to be open and use the tools available to make that happen. Their customers, partners, prospects and employees will be publishing their thoughts in some form. How do you help guide the corporate message when you just don’t know where the message will show up?

    Blogging, podcasting, video blogs (or whatever you want to call them) are all just pieces in an ever growing world of communications.

  3. kosovodad

    February 21st, 2006 at 3:20 pm

    Hello! Nice to fall in on this blog. I’m an Army officer who couldn’t agree more with the fact that not everyone needs to blog. I’m overwhelmed by the number of people who say “we need a blog…and a podcast…and an rss feed,” but give me the deer-in-the-headlights look when I ask “to do WHAT?”

    I don’t know how many times I tell my soldiers that the most important question should always be: “what issue are we trying to address?” Then, when we’ve spent enough time hashing this out (and we almost never do), the answer is almost always far more obvious that we first thought, and far LESS likely to include the originally proposed solution.

    I’m not saying blogs are bad…I even started one of my own, but we definitely need to answer some important questions before we start down that path or we are going to end up wasting a lot of our time. More importantly, we are going to waste a lot of our client’s time as well.

    Mike

One Trackback/Ping

  1. Blog Run » Blog Archive » Hierarchy as a punchline and Nvidia and Astroturf Feb 15 2006 at 3am:

    [...] Krempasky.com: You must blog. I mean, drink the Flavor Aid Don’t look behind the curtain, ignore the little man at the levers, don’t pay any attention to that man … that’s pretty much what PR bloggers are like, the great wonderful wizard of OZ when they tell every client that they need to blog. Read the full post, and get a great perspective from a great blogger. [...]

Leave a reply

Back to top